Twelve things we check on every listing we open, so you don't have to hunt for them.
On the 716 dealer websites we've read, two of the twelve do almost all the work, so they come first. Every finding is ranked by the asking dollars in the cars that miss it. That's the asking price of those cars, not money lost, and a car can miss more than one, so the figures don't add up.
Tap one to see what it catches.
The two biggest gaps
1Descriptionshalf the cars we read: under 25 words
What it looks like on a listing:
Under 25 words about the car is flagged; 60 or more is the standard. Text that is the same on every car doesn't count as words about this one.
On the lots we read: half the cars (53%) had under 25 words about the car, and 42% had none at all.
On the sample lot (all 40 listings on Oct 2, the one marked sold included; the sample Listing Check counts the 39 for sale, 20 cars and $296,900): 21 of 40 cars under 25 words, $305,800 of asking; 17 with none. 2 carry a phone number in the text.
Lot Signal Premium drafts one for every new car from what the listing shows, yours to review and post.
2Photos1 car in 6 we read: under 8 photos
What it looks like on a listing:
Under 8 is flagged; 20 or more is the standard. A coming-soon placeholder counts as none.
On the lots we read: 1 car in 6 had under 8 photos, and 1 in 13 had none.
On the sample lot: 7 cars under 8 photos, 3 of them with none; 14 at 20 or more.
In Premium now: we look at the pictures too. Each new car's draft is written from the listing, the VIN and up to 12 of its photos, so what they show that your listing doesn't say goes in: a bed cover, running boards, a badge. What a picture only suggests becomes a question for you, never a claim.
The dead ends
3No price on the car
What it looks like on a listing:
Call for price, request a price, a price behind a form, or $0.
On the lots we read: 1 lot in 9 had a car with no price, among the four cars we opened on each.
On the sample lot: 2 cars say call for price: the Prius and the Fiesta.
4Sold cars and old cars
What it looks like on a listing:
A sold badge on a car still in the inventory count, and how long each car has been up: 30 days flagged, 60 named. Age comes from the site's own date where it shows one, and is marked as an estimate where it doesn't.
On the lots we read: 1 lot in 15 had a sold car still up, among the four cars we opened on each.
On the sample lot: 1 car marked sold and still up; 2 the site itself dates past 30 days.
Eight more, on every car
5VINs
What it looks like on a listing:
Missing or wrong VINs, and no link to a history report.
On the lots we read: a VIN on 99 cars in 100. We check anyway: the recall check and the known question both start from it.
On the sample lot: 1 of 40 cars shows no VIN: $52,900 of asking.
6Mileage
What it looks like on a listing:
Missing miles, and high miles with nothing in the listing to explain them.
On the lots we read: the miles on 99 cars in 100.
On the sample lot: 1 car shows no mileage.
7Make, model, trim
What it looks like on a listing:
Misspellings and blank trims, which a search by make, model or trim can miss.
On the sample lot: Every make spelled right, every trim filled in. Nothing to flag here.
8Blank fields
What it looks like on a listing:
No color, engine, drivetrain or transmission; a wrong condition or vehicle-type tag.
On the sample lot: 13 cars with a blank color, engine, transmission or drivetrain.
9High miles, no history line
What it looks like on a listing:
High-mile cars with no one-owner or service-history line up front.
On the sample lot: 1 higher-mileage car with no owner or service line up front.
10The known question
What it looks like on a listing:
Many engines and gearboxes have a known question, and we keep the list. We check whether your listing answers it.
On the sample lot: 4 trucks, $154,200, never answer the known question on their engines.
11Wrong numbers, dead links
What it looks like on a listing:
Extra phone numbers, broken email links, social buttons that go nowhere, leftover template text.
On the sample lot: One phone number, working links. Nothing to flag here.
12Cars to check in your feed
What it looks like on a listing:
Listings with no VIN or a misspelled make: the first things to check if you send your cars to other sites. We only see your website, so we say check the feed, never that a car was turned away.
On the sample lot: The F-250 Super Duty with no VIN, $52,900 of asking.
Every listing we open gets every check, and the audit names the cars that miss any of them. Everything we say comes from your own listing, a VIN decode, or what you tell us. If we need a fact we don't have, we ask you for it instead of guessing.
How the Lot Score works. Four pockets, 25 points each.
| How each car earns its points | Sample lot | |
|---|---|---|
| Photos | 1 point at 20 or more photos, half at 8 to 19, none under 8. The pocket is the lot's average. | 15 of 25 |
| Descriptions | 1 point at 60 or more real words; half at 25 to 59, or in ALL CAPS, or with a phone number in it; none under 25. | 10 of 25 |
| Missing info | Starts at 1. No VIN costs 0.4, no miles 0.3, a misspelled make or model 0.2, a blank color, engine, transmission or drivetrain 0.1. | 24 of 25 |
| Dead ends | The lot starts at 25. Minus 3 per sold car still up, 2 per car past 30 days, 3 past 60, 5 for a dead email link or inventory button, 2 for extra phone numbers, 2 for template copy. | 18 of 25 |
| Lot Score | Add the four. 80 and up is Green, 50 to 79 is Yellow, under 50 is Red. | 67 of 100, Yellow |
Because the first three pockets are lot averages, one bad listing on a big lot barely moves the score; a pattern does. For scale: on the 716 lots we've read (four cars opened on each), Photos averaged 16 of 25 and Descriptions 11 of 25, and Descriptions was the lowest pocket, or tied for lowest, on 3 lots in 4 (Dead ends needs the whole lot over time, so four cars can't measure it).